Why khatna in muslim

You are commenting using your WordPress. You are commenting using your Google account. You are commenting using your Twitter account. You are commenting using your Facebook account. Notify me of new comments via email. Notify me of new posts via email. Skip to content. To understand this, let us look at what Islamic texts say about female circumcision. Italics added I am not an Arabic scholar, but it is evident from these various translations that different Arabic and Islamic scholars have interpreted the same message in slightly different and contradictory ways.

Like this: Like Loading Previous We need a Bohra Revolution. May 19, at am Reply. May 20, at am Reply. May 19, at pm Reply. May 20, at pm Reply. June 21, at am Reply. August 12, at am Reply. Best wishes, Another former bohri Like Like. March 2, at pm Reply. March 3, at am. August 21, at pm Reply. August 23, at pm Reply. August 28, at am Reply. October 28, at pm Reply. October 29, at am Reply. Look forward to hearing from you! January 20, at pm Reply. Yes we should question everything!

The past three generations of Syednas come from a powerful family that has historically fostered close ties with relevant ruling parties, and have continued to do so with Prime Minister Narendra Modi. They have a huge influence on the community, which happens to form a large vote bank in his stronghold, Gujarat. He has praised their patriotism, and called them an example for the country. In September , the case was referred to a five-judge constitution bench and has yet to be decided — leaving the practice not yet technically illegal.

In another study, the women consistently noted delayed or absent orgasm and reduced sensation, physical scar tissue, and psychological trauma responses during sexual contact, with a pervasive sense of sexual inadequacy. So yes that did affect my marital life a lot. Every khatna is different.

She had one long nail; on the index finger. As a result, biological impacts can vary. The scars are not just physical. What remains consistent is the experience of pain and violation a child associates with the process — and consequently, with sexual touch. Dr Kapadia gently advocates against it when her patients come to her with their doubts.

You have to prove it. How do you do that when the mothers have asked for it to be done? When I first saw it, I had no idea what I was seeing. Until you see multiple patients from the same community and then realise why the genitals look a little different. There is no way we can medicalise this as a procedure — it is not going to be taught in medical schools, as it serves no medical purpose.

Female circumcision was first prohibited by white English colonial missionaries in Kenya in the early 20th century — the original carriers of the white saviour complex — and when it was eventually banned in , girls would go to the forest to willingly cut each other and themselves, in a protest called Ngaitana.

It was an assertion of tribal identity, and a furious protest against its colonial erasure. The mutilation is also affecting marriages.

Couples are finally admitting to it but only in one-on-one confidential meetings with the petitioners. The sad part is I will never know. One reason why khatna continues is because the Syneda, or the Bohra high priest, refuses to engage on the issue either with the women or the media. The United Nations has declared female genital mutilation a human rights violation but there is no ban in India. Young girls are still being taken to midwives and to doctors in Bohra-run hospitals.

An anonymous Bohra woman petitioned the Syedna in but drew a blank but the current one in which Masooma, Aarefa and Insia have identified themselves is gathering steam with over 45, signatures. Slowly, the issue is becoming less taboo. She initially agreed only to a tape-recorded interview but soon sent a message saying she wanted to be a part of the campaign to stop FGM. The family is united now and willing to withstand any backlash that comes their way in the fight against FGM.

The fight is picking up slowly. Masooma and Aarefa plan to finally ask for a ban when they take their petition to the ministries of women and child development, law and health. Sahiyo members are analysing the results of an online survey they conducted. Non-Bohra women are joining the fight too.

Family and child protection lawyer Tavawalla views khatna as a gross violation because children are not able to protect themselves. Women from the community agree. The secrecy comes wrapped in deceit and betrayal. And a grave form of abuse on young minds and bodies. There was no ill intention.

This article looks at the reasons for this. In Islam circumcision is also known as tahara , meaning purification. Circumcision is not mentioned in the Qur'an but it is highlighted in the Sunnah the Prophet Muhammad 's recorded words and actions. In the Sunnah, Muhammad stated that circumcision was a "law for men. The main reason given for the ritual is cleanliness.

It is essential that every Muslim washes before praying. It is important that no urine is left on the body. Muslims believe the removal of the foreksin makes it easier to keep the penis clean because urine can't get trapped there. Supporters of circumcision also argue that excrements may collect under the foreskin which may lead to fatal diseases such as cancer.

For the majority of Muslims, circumcision is seen as an introduction to the Islamic faith and a sign of belonging. In Islam there is no fixed age for circumcision.